Skip to content

Next Monthly Card Show is September 28th. Register Now to Become a Vendor

  • Supplies
    • All Supplies
    • Top Loaders
    • One Touch Magnetic card Holders
    • Soft Sleeves
    • Semi-Rigid Card Holders
    • Storage Boxes
    • Card Bins & Misc Accessories
    • Binder Pages
    • Binders/ Folios
      • Top Loader Folio
      • 12 Pocket Folio
      • 9 Pocket Folio
      • 4 Pocket Folio
    • Sports Equipment Display Cases
    • Gaming Playmats & Other Supplies
    • MISC Supplies
    • Graded Card Supplies
    • Comic Supplies
  • Non Sports Cards
    • Pokémon
      • Pokémon Singles
      • Pokémon Preorders
      • Pokémon Sealed Products
    • Magic The Gathering
    • Disney Lorcana
      • Disney Lorcana Preorders
    • Yu-Gi-Oh!
      • Yu-Gi-Oh! Booster Boxes
      • Yu-Gi-Oh! Decks / Speed Duals / Tins / Etc
      • Yu-Gi-Oh! Preorders
    • Marvel
      • Marvel Boxes
      • Marvel Singles
    • Misc Non Sports
    • Duel Masters TCG
    • Neopets TCG
  • Sports Cards
    • Hockey
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
      • 1980's Vintage Hockey Singles
      • 1970s Vintage Singles
    • Baseball
      • Baseball Sealed Products
      • Baseball Singles
    • Basketball
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
    • Football
      • Sealed Product
      • Singles
    • UFC
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
    • Soccer
      • Soccer Sealed Products
      • Soccer Singles
    • Wrestling
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
    • Golf
    • Misc Sports
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
  • Autographs
    • Hockey Autographs
    • Baseball Autographs
    • Football Autographs
  • New Horizon Sports Cards Show
  • Grading Services
  • DRAGON SHIELD Sale
  • Yu-Gi-Oh! Branded Supplies SALE

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • United States USD $
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Overtime Sportscards
  • Supplies
    • All Supplies
    • Top Loaders
    • One Touch Magnetic card Holders
    • Soft Sleeves
    • Semi-Rigid Card Holders
    • Storage Boxes
    • Card Bins & Misc Accessories
    • Binder Pages
    • Binders/ Folios
      • Top Loader Folio
      • 12 Pocket Folio
      • 9 Pocket Folio
      • 4 Pocket Folio
    • Sports Equipment Display Cases
    • Gaming Playmats & Other Supplies
    • MISC Supplies
    • Graded Card Supplies
    • Comic Supplies
  • Non Sports Cards
    • Pokémon
      • Pokémon Singles
      • Pokémon Preorders
      • Pokémon Sealed Products
    • Magic The Gathering
    • Disney Lorcana
      • Disney Lorcana Preorders
    • Yu-Gi-Oh!
      • Yu-Gi-Oh! Booster Boxes
      • Yu-Gi-Oh! Decks / Speed Duals / Tins / Etc
      • Yu-Gi-Oh! Preorders
    • Marvel
      • Marvel Boxes
      • Marvel Singles
    • Misc Non Sports
    • Duel Masters TCG
    • Neopets TCG
  • Sports Cards
    • Hockey
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
      • 1980's Vintage Hockey Singles
      • 1970s Vintage Singles
    • Baseball
      • Baseball Sealed Products
      • Baseball Singles
    • Basketball
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
    • Football
      • Sealed Product
      • Singles
    • UFC
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
    • Soccer
      • Soccer Sealed Products
      • Soccer Singles
    • Wrestling
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
    • Golf
    • Misc Sports
      • Sealed Products
      • Singles
  • Autographs
    • Hockey Autographs
    • Baseball Autographs
    • Football Autographs
  • New Horizon Sports Cards Show
  • Grading Services
  • DRAGON SHIELD Sale
  • Yu-Gi-Oh! Branded Supplies SALE

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • United States USD $
Cart

Item added to your cart

View cart

Filter:

Availability
0 selected
Reset
Availability
Price
The highest price is $2,999.99 Reset
$
$
Remove all

49 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

49 products

Availability
Clear
Price

The highest price is $2,999.99

$
$
Clear
Remove all
Remove all

49 products

  • Connor Bedard 2023-24 Upper Deck UD SP-1 Rookie Card RC PSA 10 Chicago Blackhawks

    Connor Bedard 2023-24 Upper Deck UD SP-1 Rookie Card RC PSA 10 Chicago Blackhawks

    Connor Bedard 2023-24 Upper Deck UD SP-1 Rookie Card RC PSA 10 Chicago Blackhawks

    Regular price $2,999.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $2,999.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Connor Bedard 2024 Upper Deck Victory Black PSA 10 Rookie Card Chicago Blackhawks National Hockey Card Day RC

    Connor Bedard 2024 Upper Deck Victory Black PSA 10 Rookie Card Chicago Blackhawks National Hockey Card Day RC

    Connor Bedard 2024 Upper Deck Victory Black PSA 10 Rookie Card Chicago Blackhawks National Hockey Card Day RC

    Regular price $2,499.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $2,499.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Sam Bennett 2015-16 SP Authentic Future Watch BLACK PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #238 Calgary Flames

    Sam Bennett 2015-16 SP Authentic Future Watch BLACK PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #238 Calgary Flames

    Sam Bennett 2015-16 SP Authentic Future Watch BLACK PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #238 Calgary Flames

    Regular price $999.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $999.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Carey Price UD ARTIFACTS Gold 40/50 Rookie Card RC #205 PSA 10 Montreal Canadiens

    Carey Price UD ARTIFACTS Gold 40/50 Rookie Card RC #205 PSA 10 Montreal Canadiens

    Carey Price UD ARTIFACTS Gold 40/50 Rookie Card RC #205 PSA 10 Montreal Canadiens

    Regular price $999.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $999.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Sidney Crosby 2022-23 SP Authentic Retro Acetate Future Watch #181 PSA 9 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Sidney Crosby 2022-23 SP Authentic Retro Acetate Future Watch #181 PSA 9 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Sidney Crosby 2022-23 SP Authentic Retro Acetate Future Watch #181 PSA 9 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $999.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $999.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • NIKITA KUCHEROV 2013-14 Upper Deck Young Guns Rookie Card RC #483 Tampa Bay Lightning Series 2

    NIKITA KUCHEROV 2013-14 Upper Deck Young Guns Rookie Card RC #483 Tampa Bay Lightning Series 2

    NIKITA KUCHEROV 2013-14 Upper Deck Young Guns Rookie Card RC #483 Tampa Bay Lightning Series 2

    Regular price $789.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $789.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Sean Monahan Panini Prizm Update Rookie Anthology Gold Auto 04/10 PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #330 Calgary Flames

    Sean Monahan Panini Prizm Update Rookie Anthology Gold Auto 04/10 PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #330 Calgary Flames

    Sean Monahan Panini Prizm Update Rookie Anthology Gold Auto 04/10 PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #330 Calgary Flames

    Regular price $599.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $599.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Tim Stutzle 2020-21 UD Ice Premieres Rookie Card /99 RC #198 PSA 9 Ottawa Senators

    Tim Stutzle 2020-21 UD Ice Premieres Rookie Card /99 RC #198 PSA 9 Ottawa Senators

    Tim Stutzle 2020-21 UD Ice Premieres Rookie Card /99 RC #198 PSA 9 Ottawa Senators

    Regular price $599.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $599.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • RYAN NUGENT-HOPKINS 2011-12 UD The Cup Emblems of Endorsement 3/15 Rookie Card BGS 9 - Edmonton Oilers RC

    RYAN NUGENT-HOPKINS 2011-12 UD The Cup Emblems of Endorsement 3/15 Rookie Card BGS 9 - Edmonton Oilers RC

    RYAN NUGENT-HOPKINS 2011-12 UD The Cup Emblems of Endorsement 3/15 Rookie Card BGS 9 - Edmonton Oilers RC

    Regular price $549.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $549.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • TAYLOR HALL 2010-11 Panini Luxury Suite GOLD 4/10 (jersey #) BGS 9 #132 Edmonton Oilers

    TAYLOR HALL 2010-11 Panini Luxury Suite GOLD 4/10 (jersey #) BGS 9 #132 Edmonton Oilers

    TAYLOR HALL 2010-11 Panini Luxury Suite GOLD 4/10 (jersey #) BGS 9 #132 Edmonton Oilers

    Regular price $499.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $499.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Clayton Keller 20178-18 Black Diamond Quad Diamond Relic Rookies 95/99 BGS 9.5 True Gem #BDR-CK Arizona Coyotes

    Clayton Keller 20178-18 Black Diamond Quad Diamond Relic Rookies 95/99 BGS 9.5 True Gem #BDR-CK Arizona Coyotes

    Clayton Keller 20178-18 Black Diamond Quad Diamond Relic Rookies 95/99 BGS 9.5 True Gem #BDR-CK Arizona Coyotes

    Regular price $499.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $499.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • JAROMIR JAGR 1996-97 Upper Deck UD Game Jersey GJ4 Pittsburgh Penguins

    JAROMIR JAGR 1996-97 Upper Deck UD Game Jersey GJ4 Pittsburgh Penguins

    JAROMIR JAGR 1996-97 Upper Deck UD Game Jersey GJ4 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $499.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $499.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • ALEXANDER ALEX OVECHKIN - 2015-16 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Autographed Card #SOTT-AO PSA 8 - Washington Capitals

    ALEXANDER ALEX OVECHKIN - 2015-16 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Autographed Card #SOTT-AO PSA 8 - Washington Capitals

    ALEXANDER ALEX OVECHKIN - 2015-16 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Autographed Card #SOTT-AO PSA 8 - Washington Capitals

    Regular price $424.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $424.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • MAX DOMI 2015-16 Upper Deck UD The CUP Rookie Autographed Patch Card RC #198 - Arizona Coyotes - Toronto Maple Leafs

    MAX DOMI 2015-16 Upper Deck UD The CUP Rookie Autographed Patch Card RC #198 - Arizona Coyotes - Toronto Maple Leafs

    MAX DOMI 2015-16 Upper Deck UD The CUP Rookie Autographed Patch Card RC #198 - Arizona Coyotes - Toronto Maple Leafs

    Regular price $349.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $349.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • NEAL BROTEN Autographed 1982-83 O-Pee-Chee OPC Rookie card RC #164 PSA 9 / Auto 9 - Minnesota North Stars

    NEAL BROTEN Autographed 1982-83 O-Pee-Chee OPC Rookie card RC #164 PSA 9 / Auto 9 - Minnesota North Stars

    NEAL BROTEN Autographed 1982-83 O-Pee-Chee OPC Rookie card RC #164 PSA 9 / Auto 9 - Minnesota North Stars

    Regular price $299.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $299.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 UD Artifacts /599 Rookie Card RC #254 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 UD Artifacts /599 Rookie Card RC #254 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 UD Artifacts /599 Rookie Card RC #254 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $299.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $299.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Ray Bourque 1980-81 O-Pee-Chee PSA 7 Rookie Card #140 Boston Bruins RC

    Ray Bourque 1980-81 O-Pee-Chee PSA 7 Rookie Card #140 Boston Bruins RC

    Ray Bourque 1980-81 O-Pee-Chee PSA 7 Rookie Card #140 Boston Bruins RC

    Regular price $299.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $299.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • WAYNE GRETZKY Autographed 1985-86 Topps All-Star Sticker card PSA Authenticated - Edmonton Oilers

    WAYNE GRETZKY Autographed 1985-86 Topps All-Star Sticker card PSA Authenticated - Edmonton Oilers

    WAYNE GRETZKY Autographed 1985-86 Topps All-Star Sticker card PSA Authenticated - Edmonton Oilers

    Regular price $249.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $249.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • TYLER BERTUZZI Upper Deck UD Young Guns Exclusives 57/100 Rookie Card RC BGS 9.5 Detroit Red Wings - Toronto Maple Leafs

    TYLER BERTUZZI Upper Deck UD Young Guns Exclusives 57/100 Rookie Card RC BGS 9.5 Detroit Red Wings - Toronto Maple Leafs

    TYLER BERTUZZI Upper Deck UD Young Guns Exclusives 57/100 Rookie Card RC BGS 9.5 Detroit Red Wings - Toronto Maple Leafs

    Regular price $249.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $249.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 UD MVP Rookie Card RC #303 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 UD MVP Rookie Card RC #303 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 UD MVP Rookie Card RC #303 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $199.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $199.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Wayne Gretzky 1990-91 Upper Deck FRENCH PSA 10 Card #55 Los Angeles LA Kings

    Wayne Gretzky 1990-91 Upper Deck FRENCH PSA 10 Card #55 Los Angeles LA Kings

    Wayne Gretzky 1990-91 Upper Deck FRENCH PSA 10 Card #55 Los Angeles LA Kings

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Evan Bouchard 2018-19 Upper Deck Young Guns Rookie Card KSA 10 - Edmonton Oilers RC #221

    Evan Bouchard 2018-19 Upper Deck Young Guns Rookie Card KSA 10 - Edmonton Oilers RC #221

    Evan Bouchard 2018-19 Upper Deck Young Guns Rookie Card KSA 10 - Edmonton Oilers RC #221

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Duncan Keith 2005-06 Fleer Ultra PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #211 Chicago Blackhawks

    Duncan Keith 2005-06 Fleer Ultra PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #211 Chicago Blackhawks

    Duncan Keith 2005-06 Fleer Ultra PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #211 Chicago Blackhawks

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Evgeni Malkin 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #322 PSA 10 Pittsburgh Penguins

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Anze Kopitar 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #314 PSA 10 Los Angeles Kings

    Anze Kopitar 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #314 PSA 10 Los Angeles Kings

    Anze Kopitar 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #314 PSA 10 Los Angeles Kings

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Anze Kopitar 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #314 PSA 10 Los Angeles Kings

    Anze Kopitar 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #314 PSA 10 Los Angeles Kings

    Anze Kopitar 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #314 PSA 10 Los Angeles Kings

    Regular price $149.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $149.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • JOHN TAVARES 2009-10 Upper Deck UD Young Guns Rookie Card RC BGS 9.5 True Gem+ New York Islanders - Toronto Maple Leafs

    JOHN TAVARES 2009-10 Upper Deck UD Young Guns Rookie Card RC BGS 9.5 True Gem+ New York Islanders - Toronto Maple Leafs

    JOHN TAVARES 2009-10 Upper Deck UD Young Guns Rookie Card RC BGS 9.5 True Gem+ New York Islanders - Toronto Maple Leafs

    Regular price $124.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $124.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Joe Thornton 1996-97 Upper Deck ICE RC PSA 9 Rookie Card #116 San Jose Sharks

    Joe Thornton 1996-97 Upper Deck ICE RC PSA 9 Rookie Card #116 San Jose Sharks

    Joe Thornton 1996-97 Upper Deck ICE RC PSA 9 Rookie Card #116 San Jose Sharks

    Regular price $99.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $99.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Vincent Lecavalier 1997-98 Black Diamond - Double Diamond RC PSA 9 Rookie #150 Card Tampa Bay Lightning

    Vincent Lecavalier 1997-98 Black Diamond - Double Diamond RC PSA 9 Rookie #150 Card Tampa Bay Lightning

    Vincent Lecavalier 1997-98 Black Diamond - Double Diamond RC PSA 9 Rookie #150 Card Tampa Bay Lightning

    Regular price $99.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $99.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Quinton Byfield 2021-22 Upper Deck UD Canvas Program of Excellence PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #C256 Los Angeles Kings / Team Canada

    Quinton Byfield 2021-22 Upper Deck UD Canvas Program of Excellence PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #C256 Los Angeles Kings / Team Canada

    Quinton Byfield 2021-22 Upper Deck UD Canvas Program of Excellence PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #C256 Los Angeles Kings / Team Canada

    Regular price $99.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $99.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Ryan Getzlaf 2005-06 Rookie Class PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #38 Anaheim Ducks

    Ryan Getzlaf 2005-06 Rookie Class PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #38 Anaheim Ducks

    Ryan Getzlaf 2005-06 Rookie Class PSA 10 Rookie Card RC #38 Anaheim Ducks

    Regular price $99.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $99.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Phil Kessel 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #303 PSA 10 Boston Bruins

    Phil Kessel 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #303 PSA 10 Boston Bruins

    Phil Kessel 2006-07 Flair Showcase Rookie Card RC #303 PSA 10 Boston Bruins

    Regular price $99.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $99.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Daniel Alfredsson 1995-96 SP RC PSA 9 Rookie Card #100 Ottawa Senators

    Daniel Alfredsson 1995-96 SP RC PSA 9 Rookie Card #100 Ottawa Senators

    Daniel Alfredsson 1995-96 SP RC PSA 9 Rookie Card #100 Ottawa Senators

    Regular price $79.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $79.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • Vincent Lecavalier 1997-98 Black Diamond - RC PSA 9 Rookie #150 Card Tampa Bay Lightning

    Vincent Lecavalier 1997-98 Black Diamond - RC PSA 9 Rookie #150 Card Tampa Bay Lightning

    Vincent Lecavalier 1997-98 Black Diamond - RC PSA 9 Rookie #150 Card Tampa Bay Lightning

    Regular price $79.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $79.99 CAD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 1
  • 2

Sign up to our email list

Get updates on shows, promotions, new arrivals and exclusive offers.

Unit H21 / Box 421

New Horizon Mall

260300 Writing Creek Crescent

Rockyview County(Balzac), AB

T4A 0X8

info@overtimegrading.com

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • United States USD $
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
© 2024, Overtime Sportscards Powered by Shopify
  • Refund policy
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of service
  • Shipping policy
  • Contact information
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.